Criticism of Quitak’s Child observation Essay Example for Free

Criticism of Quitaks Child observation EssayQuitak first explains that she is working on the assumption that the problematic aspects of our experience contain the maximum potential. However I think it is pregnant to clarify from the bring outset, how she reached this assumption, as the reader does not know whether she went into the observation with this belief or whether these assumptions were developed as a result of her observation. There is another important omission relating to who the author actually is. She hasnt positively stated that she is a Social Work student, although this is implied when she states that her observations had implications for social work. Therefore it is difficult to ascertain her purpose for carrying out the observations.Furthermore Quitak fails to mention how she came to select the barbarian included in her observations, how many observation sessions took place and the space of the sessions. Therefore the reader is unable to assess whether there were any issues of bias involved in her endurance process.The fact that she is the product of English middle class parents means she may be going into the charter with particular assumptions, as she is observing a child who has a Palestinian parent. A significant orbit which was lacking in her observations was her inability to tune in to Selenas inner world (pg 250), although Quitak does acknowledge this omission. She didnt really try to question and understand Selenas behaviour or how she might be mite when she demonstrated behaviour she didnt like, which meant her observation suffered as a result. King (2010) stresses the importance of to access the childs emotional world.